Occupy Patriarchy disrupts Law Enforcement’s “Anti-Sex-Trafficking” Conference

14 Jun

The H.E.A.T. Conference is Just Another Excuse to Police Us!

 

The H.E.A.T conference organizers claim that their intention is to combat the sex trafficking of children and find “solutions” to “respond” to children coerced into sex work, in order to “Stop Human Exploitation and Trafficking.”  We are here to expose the blatant LIE in this claim. The official, police-sanctioned campaign to combat the commercial sex trafficking of children is nothing more than a patronizing, patriarchal guise that is being used to support intensified repression of sex workers and the further empowerment of police agencies at their expense.  This conference is actually a launching pad for measures that will increase policing, such as national coordination of police surveillance and the introduction of ballot initiatives to further criminalize prostitution in California.  This is yet another instance of police and the criminal justice system colluding for increased policing in places where sex work takes place, using the false pretense of “concern” for the most exploited people in society as a cover.

Ultimately, no form of work is truly consensual given the conditions of work under Capitalism. We all have to sell our labor to survive. But the conditions of sale are not equal for all of us. For some people, sex work is just a better choice, given the poverty of viable alternatives. It is only thanks to the power of religious institutions and their policing of morality that the spotlight gets shone onto those of us who labor physically in the bedroom.  We reject any moral policing of our bodies.

Clearly, human trafficking is a heinous practice, but the perpetual focus on sex is uncritically sensationalist, and its shock value is exploited by anti-sex-trafficking groups present at the HEAT conference in pursuit of their own moralizing, often religious, agendas. Forced labour and human trafficking is a problem not only in the sex industry, but in all forms of work. Many people are forced to migrate, to labour clandestinely, or to engage in forms of labour they might otherwise never agree to. Often this means performing dangerous or damaging physical labor. The problem of human trafficking includes people who work in construction, hospitality, or agriculture, who also find themselves at the mercy of rings of exploitation; but the organizers of the HEAT conference are silent about these forms of forced labour.

“When the vice squad does stings, the facade that they come in like white knights, capture the pimps and free the prostitutes is a cynical far cry from the truth, including with minors. Often times when the police do stings they will first engage in sexual activity with the workers to bait them in for the arrest. This shit is common knowledge between sex workers and is some of the grounds for hatred in the industry between sex workers and the police. The police, when a sex worker has faced violence by a pimp or john and files a report is often times told that their file will not be accepted.That they have the power to use and move our bodies in any way they please is the source of this patriarchal dynamic.

-  anonymous sex worker

No doubt many participants in H.E.A.T have positive intentions, but this conference is about arrests, convictions, imprisonment, and deportation– in short, it is about refining the state’s techniques of repression, not healing victims of trafficking or empowering sex workers. H.E.A.T. will only lead to greater policing of communities; it will do little to address the conditions that cause people to engage in exploitative sex work, such as poverty, lack of access to education, no hope of a future outside of the black market, or the lack of public assistance. It will, in fact, cause harm to the very populations it targets.  Some nonprofit organizations represented at H.E.A.T. provide valuable resources that are otherwise unavailable to support sex workers, such as queer friendly healthcare, but by participating in conferences aimed at collaboration with policing efforts, nonprofits become collaborators with the violent arm of the state that robs government social programs of resources and funds that instead get funneled into already over-inflated police departments and DA offices, and which feeds the metastasizing cancer of the prison-industrial complex. In this way, nonprofits end up alienating the very populations they are supposed to serve. Policing of sex work is, in itself, an act of class, race, and gender oppression.


Who’s Who in the H.E.A.T. Conference

61 official speakers are law enforcement agents, DA workers, or politicians with anti sex-worker reputations.  39 speakers are individuals or representatives of non-profits. The vast majority of these work directly with law enforcement or politicians to criminalize sex workers.  Where is the voice of the sex workers?

- Linda Smith- anti-abortionist, anti-sex politician whose political history includes sponsoring a bill to illegalize sex between minors

- SAGE, which has opposed measures for sex workers’ decriminalization , and profits from sex-work-related arrests through running their “Johns Schools”

- Nancy O’Malley- Alameda County District Attorney

- Daphne Phung- Executive director of Californians against Slavery, the main proponents of an upcoming ballot measure (“CASE Act”) which criminalizes providing support to sex workers in the name of preventing sex trafficking.

9 Responses to “Occupy Patriarchy disrupts Law Enforcement’s “Anti-Sex-Trafficking” Conference”

  1. cydnova June 14, 2012 at 6:00 pm #

    As the ‘anonymous’ person behind the second quote – I am super upset and annoyed that you decontextualized my quote (which included critical feedback towards the organizers of this protest) and then used it without even bothering to ask permission. You could have written me a message. Re-using something someone says to support your own agenda, especially when it is something as personal as that quote, is goddamn rude. Take it out.

  2. Cristine Sardina June 14, 2012 at 11:07 pm #

    The BOJ “Trafficking Report” does not support its own statistics. Most people arrested are Hispanic & Black men & very few arrests have led to convictions

  3. Cat June 17, 2012 at 9:40 am #

    Thank you very much for addressing the issue of sensationalism with efforts to fight human trafficking. You are spot on in saying, “Often this means performing dangerous or damaging physical labor. The problem of human trafficking includes people who work in construction, hospitality, or agriculture, who also find themselves at the mercy of rings of exploitation; but the organizers of the HEAT conference are silent about these forms of forced labour.”

    There are also good resources

    Sex Work, Trafficking: Understanding the Difference
    Articles referenced
    Urban Justice Center

    http://www.urbanjustice.org/pdf/publications/KDTD_Human_Trafficking_And_Sex_Work.pdf

    Sex Work vs. Trafficking: Understanding the Difference by Melissa Ditmore, Independent consultant

    http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/blog/2008/05/06/sex-work-trafficking-understanding-difference

    http://www.alternet.org/story/84987/?page=2

    I do have a question though/comment. what will the occupy movement do in the fight against human trafficking? I see that you stopped the conference in advocate for the rights of sex workers, but what about the issue of human trafficking?
    Please advise

    Thanks so much
    In solidarity

  4. bebopper76 June 18, 2012 at 8:02 pm #

    What amazes me is how the media and government officials are so enthusiastic about pushing negative stereotypes, and lies about prostitution like the idea that all clients of prostitutes are rapists, and that all prostitutes cannot think for themselves, since they believe they don’t have a brain in their head. They say that all prostitutes are either forced against their will or mentally ill.
    I guess the people who buy newspaper companies and media outlets hate prostitution, and love to tell lies about it.

  5. bebopper76 June 18, 2012 at 8:45 pm #

    COLLEGE PARK, GA June 13 2012 – A College Park police officer has quit and another is still on the force after prostitutes alleged having sex with them to have their cases dropped.

    Former Officer Horace Roberts, of College Park, resigned from the force in April after College Park police investigators attempted to question him about the allegations. Roberts told CBS Atlanta News that he had no inappropriate relationships with any prostitute and resigned from the force because of stress.

    Officer Marcus Dennard, of Fayetteville, is still assigned to the department’s Special Operations division after the department investigated and closed the case.

    According to a city of College Park police complaint, Jessica Flournoy, 23, and Jenny Clementi, 29, claimed Roberts and Dennard requested sexual favors in return for their charges related to prostitution to be dropped.

    http://privateofficerbreakingnews.blogspot.com/2012/06/college-park-police-officers-accused-of.html

  6. bebopper76 June 18, 2012 at 8:54 pm #

    What is striking about many street prostitutes is that they often regard even the more severe abuses they encounter at the hands of the police as little more than hazards of the job. This is not because these women lack a sense of justice. It is because, in the matter-of-fact words of Donna Argenot, a black woman in her late twenties with a gentle, thoughtful manner, “We can’t do anything about it anyway. The Police know who we are and where to come get us.”

    http://www.bayswan.org/jeremy1.html

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Occupy Oakland Patriarchy outing people in the sex trade? | postwhoreamerica - June 18, 2012

    […] writes extensively on anti-trafficking and anti-prostitution campaigns, responds: …in the statement announcing their protest/disruption, [Occupy Oakland Patriarchy] prominently use a quote from my article in Bitch magazine, […]

  2. Police are forcing prostitutes to lie against their will about Sex Trafficking | The Myth of Sex Trafficking and Sex Slavery, Research, Lies, Facts, Fact Sheet, Truth about Human Trafficking statistics and Prostitution - June 18, 2012

    […] http://oaklandoccupypatriarchy.wordpress.com/2012/06/14/occupy-patriarchy-disrupts-h-e-a-t-watch-law… […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 61 other followers

%d bloggers like this: